Pizza restaurants

Little Sicily Pizzeria

3.7 180 reviews Closed 227 N Main St, Standish, MI 48658, United States

Discover this place

Little Sicily Pizzeria, nestled in the heart of Standish, MI, has quickly become a beloved dining destination for pizza enthusiasts. With raving reviews highlighting their homemade, secret sauces and traditional recipes, it's no wonder why many consider it the best pizza in town. Randy R. E. describes the Sicilian pizza as a culinary masterpiece, featuring double layers of pepperoni, cheese, and a rich tomato sauce, all enveloped in a thick, buttery crust that’s simply irresistible.

Customers consistently praise the welcoming atmosphere and the friendly service. Jennifer Reittenbach succinctly sums it up with her endorsement of the scrumptious pizza and garlic cheese breadsticks. For those seeking authenticity, Crys Snow, a New York native, was pleasantly surprised by the high-quality offerings at Little Sicily, claiming it’s the best pizza she’s had in northern Michigan.

As a food reviewer, I’m enamored by Little Sicily Pizzeria's commitment to quality and flavor. Their ability to blend traditional recipes with fresh ingredients is commendable, ensuring a delightful experience for both carry-out and delivery. This pizzeria is more than just a meal; it’s a culinary journey that captures the essence of Sicilian heritage, making it a staple for locals and visitors alike.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fast service

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner

Atmosphere

Casual
Quiet

Crowd

Family-friendly
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Little Sicily Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Little Sicily Pizzeria

3.7

180 reviews

100%

30%

17%

40%

Review highlights

Based on 180 reviews

Little Sicily Pizzeria in Standish, MI, is widely recognized for its authentic, old-style pizza that consistently satisfies local customers. Reviewers frequently praise the distinctive homemade sauces, with options catering to varied tastes, and appreciate generous toppings that set the pies apart. The quality of both carryout and delivery orders is noted to be reliable, maintaining the restaurant’s high standards. Many highlight the warm, friendly service and timely order preparation, contributing to an overall positive dining experience. The establishment also earns commendation for its complementary menu items like garlic cheese breadsticks. Patrons often compare it favorably to other local pizzerias, emphasizing the genuine Sicilian influence and traditional flavors that keep customers returning. Overall, Little Sicily Pizzeria enjoys a strong reputation for consistent food quality, authentic taste, and attentive service within the community.

Randy R. E.

Jun 13, 2025

the best pizza in town, even more with there special Sauce homemade and a very kept secret to the recipe for years carry out or delivered they're all fantastic but my specialty is the Sicilian depends what kind of sauce you like they've got two different organic sauces I like the original tomatoes and spiced ingredients that can never gove out double rows of pepperoni double rows of cheese and double rows of pizza sauce oven baked in a super deep dish pan so delicious with homemade thick deep but soft crust that surrounds the edge coated with a little butter a little bit of garlic oh my goodness I can't stand even talking about it I just ate a half of a pizza earyler and I'm ready to blowed up already from eating half before i could stop..

Jennifer Reittenbach

Jun 04, 2025

All I can say is YUMMY pizza and bread sticks garlic cheese.

laura welch

Jun 04, 2025

I love their pizza. Standish has 3 pizza restaurants and I have tryed them all. I think from my own experience Little Sicily is the Best. There pizza is old style and they will always have my business!

Crys Snow

May 22, 2025

Born and raised in NY. Just staying in Standish for a few nights and really wanted pizza but was scared to try any. Saw a sign that said Sicily... (father is Sicilian) so I pulled in. Hands down, only 4 years of living in northern Michigan, it is the best pizza i've had thus far. And my picky 2.5yr old agrees, and really he's the only one that matters!!

Scott Dark

May 15, 2025

Pizza was great, ready at pickup time,friendly. No complaints.

Ron Lawrence

Apr 26, 2025

I've been eating pizza here for years. The place has been around awhile an sadly it shows in its appearance. But one thing that hasn't changed over the years, is how fantastic their pizza still tastes. It's well worth the 3 mile drive off I-75 to get a pizza. I suggest you order about a half hour before you expect to get there.

stacy holloway

Apr 07, 2025

During these difficult times its important to give those credit for going above and beyond for great service. I just finished my AWSOME pizza and fresh salad. It was our first delivery and we are DEFINITELY are going to order more in the future. If I were you I would order your next diner here.

Stephanie Marie

Mar 18, 2025

Ordered pizzas here for dinner. We were staying in the area for the weekend. The pizza was delicious. We ordered a BLT pizza, house deluxe pizza, and the cheese and garlic bread. It all was so so so good. I want to come back to the area just so I can stop here for some pizza. I'll be back some day!